Belshina and Kama, or cheap and cheerful!

Content:

• About Belshina products
• About Kama tires
• Kama and Belshina: similarities and differences
• Prices for popular models Kama and Belshina
• What to choose: Kama or Belshina?
• Conclusion

High-quality tires ensure driving safety and minimize the risk of a car colliding with other vehicles and pedestrians. A competent choice of tires will give you a feeling of confidence on the road and provide comfort. Therefore, when buying winter or summer tires, it is worth considering numerous factors: brand reputation, wear resistance, speed index, load, elasticity, design features. If price plays an important role for you, you should pay attention to budget products from domestic manufacturers and brands from the CIS countries. The leaders in this segment are Kama and Belshina. We will talk about the difference between these tires and their similarities in this article. The presented review will help you choose the optimal type of car tires for the coming year and will allow you to save money on purchasing expensive imported tires.

Which winter tires are better: Cordiant or Belshina (studded or non-studded, Velcro)

Show differences only

Show differences only

About Belshina products

Before answering the question “Which is better: Belshina or Kama?”, it is worth taking a close look at the features of each brand. Let's start with the Belarusian tire plant. Belshina produces more than 300 types of tires of different sizes for the following types of equipment:

• trucks and cars;
• minibuses;
• Agreecultural machines. Agreecultural equipment;
• road construction equipment;
• all-terrain vehicles.

The Belshina plant exports more than half of its products to Russia, and also has dozens of partnership agreements with other countries. The design and appearance of winter and summer tires of this brand have patent protection. At the same time, Belshina guarantees full compliance of tires with state standards. The tires themselves have a service life of at least 5 years and are suitable for use until the tread pattern is completely erased, as they retain their functionality for a long time. In addition to the fact that the tires are characterized by high durability, it is worth noting that they provide good grip on various types of roads, as evidenced by the results of various tests.

Comparative characteristics of the products of two manufacturers

If we compare products from both Russian manufacturers, then, according to expert estimates, Belshina is somewhat inferior to Cordiant. Naturally, the whole point is that the manufacturer Cordiant produces car tires using higher and more innovative technologies, while adopting experience from global and European colleagues. And that is why most of the operational features of Cordiant car tires are of higher quality than those of Belshina products.

If we consider the advantages of Belshina over Cordiant products, it is worth noting first of all that the safety margin of these car tires is much greater. This gives the advantage of longer use of these tires, which is undoubtedly a great advantage. However, in all other characteristics, Cordiant outperforms Belshina. Grip with the road surface is much better, and this applies to all types of modifications of car tires - summer, winter, and all-season.

Also, the tread profiles of most models are more optimized than those of Belshina, and this gives an advantage in the development of such qualities as rolling resistance, aquaplaning properties, as well as speed and braking characteristics. By the way, fuel consumption is better saved with Cordiant tires, which is achieved due to the better composition of the rubber mixture.

If we compare the composition of the rubber mixture of Belshina and Cordiant products, then here the products of the first manufacturer are also somewhat inferior to Cordiant. But it is worth noting that this loss is quite small, however, a loss is a loss, and Cordiant tires are of much higher quality in this component than products from Belshina. But Belshin car tires are superior to Cordiant tires in terms of environmental friendliness, and this is also a good plus for Belshin.

If we compare the reviews of the owners of these tires with the opinions of experts, then they actually have no differences with each other. Of course, Belshina car tires outperform Cordiant in the cost of their products, and it would seem that for Russian and European drivers this should be the decisive factor when choosing a set of tires for their own vehicle. However, since recently there has been a global trend towards providing ourselves with better quality goods, Cordiant tires, nevertheless, in Europe and Russia as a whole have an advantage in this indicator - the number of sales.

About Kama tires

When answering the question of which is better: Kama or Belshina, one cannot ignore the features of the domestic brand. The Nizhnekamskshina enterprise has existed since 1973 and, almost from the very beginning of its formation, regularly receives awards for the quality of its products. The Kama catalog contains more than 250 items for the following types of transport:

• cars and trucks;
• loaders;
• all-terrain vehicles;
• agricultural machinery;
• mining dump trucks.

The company produces tires for use in various climatic conditions; there are both winter and all-season tires, as well as tires for summer. In addition, the catalog also includes models for difficult roads. Kama pays special attention to maintaining environmentally friendly production and introducing innovations. Thanks to numerous unique developments, it was possible to bring the characteristics of our products into line with international quality standards.

Kama

The Nizhnekamsshina production association operates under the auspices of PJSC Tatneft . The company occupies a flagship position among Russian tire manufacturers. Tire production was launched in 1973, and within a couple of years the association began to lead the industry and receive awards for quality products. The introduction of modern technologies into production has made it possible to improve the quality of tires and bring technical characteristics to international standards.

The Nizhnekamskshina Association produces tires for use in any climatic and road conditions - all-season, winter use, for difficult roads and quarry ones. The company's product catalog contains more than 250 items for various vehicles:

• Cars.
• Trucks.
• Agricultural machinery.
• Loaders.
• Dump trucks for quarries.

The company pays great attention to the issues of respect for the cleanliness of the environment. Modern treatment facilities have been put into operation that retain substances that can pollute the atmosphere. The production waste disposal system has been improved. Modernization of the technological process ensured economical energy consumption.

Kama and Belshina: similarities and differences

If you really want to understand which is better: Kama or Belshina, it is worth studying the key characteristics of each brand. They have several common features and significant differences, which determine the features of choice for specific operating conditions.

Similar characteristics

Both Kama and Belshina belong to the segment of budget solutions. At the same time, rubber from both productions meets the highest state standards and is very durable. Tires from each of these brands will help you operate your car with confidence for at least three seasons. Another common feature that unites Kama and Belshina tires is a wide range of models. Each of these production facilities is capable of satisfying any consumer needs.

Differences

The difference between Kama and Belshina tires appears when comparing models of the same type. For example, domestically produced winter tires demonstrate more advanced characteristics than their Belarusian counterpart. A distinctive feature of Kama tires is directional stability, high cross-country ability in low temperatures, and ease of control. Belshina tires are inferior in terms of the quality of grip on snow and ice, and also lead to increased fuel consumption, since they are inferior in such an important parameter as directional stability. For summer tires the situation is diametrically opposite. In this segment, Belshina tires are superior to Kama tires. The latter do not hold up well on wet roads, and directional stability is noticeably lower than that of their Belarusian counterparts. Taking into account the fact that Russian models created for the summer have softer tires, sharp braking and rapid acceleration on them are not as effective as on Belshina. All-season tires from both brands have almost identical characteristics, except that the Kama is noisier.

Which tires do car owners choose - BELSHINA or Cordiant?

In November 2020, according to PartReview, Cordiant tires topped more car ratings than BELSHINA:

Cordiant is chosen by owners of such cars as: Chevrolet Niva, Lexus GS, Mazda Familia, Suzuki Grand Vitara, Opel Zafira, Renault Sandero, VAZ (Lada) 2101/2103/2106, VAZ (Lada) Vesta, and others.

BELSHINA tires have not yet managed to take leading places in car ratings. You can help by adding a review about this manufacturer, indicating your car.

Prices for popular models Kama and Belshina

To make it easier to choose between tires from two brands, we suggest that you familiarize yourself with the retail prices for various models of each brand.

As you can see, Belarusian-made tires are slightly higher in price, although the difference can be called insignificant.

Which tires are more popular - BELSHINA or Cordiant?

In November 2020, on PartReview, Cordiant tires were generally more popular than BELSHINA.

In terms of votes, Cordiant tires surpassed BELSHINA:

• BELSHINA had a ratio of positive votes (43) to negative votes (16) of 27 votes.
• Cordiant had a ratio of positive votes (396) to negative votes (131) of 265 votes.

In terms of the number of reviews, Cordiant tires surpassed BELSHINA:

• There are 18 reviews written on BELSHINA tires: 12 positive, 3 neutral, 3 negative.
• There are 164 reviews written on Cordiant tires: 113 positive, 27 neutral, 24 negative.